Why Bernie is praying for rain

Adelaide coach Brenton Sanderson admits Taylor Walker could have played in the AFL this week, instead he'll be making his return in round nine while his teammates take on the Melbourne Demons and former teammate Bernie Vince.

MELBOURNE is praying for rain as former Crows best-and-fairest Bernie Vince faces Adelaide for the first time at Adelaide Oval on Saturday.

Under new coach Paul Roos, the Demons have improved to become one of the most difficult teams to score against and Vince said a low-scoring game because of inclement weather would be ideal.

MORE: TEX DUE BACK FOR COLLINGWOOD CLASH

Melbourne is averaging 10 fewer goals scored against them this season after adopting similar strategies to the ones Roos employed at Sydney and would cherish a low-scoring game.

The big choke is on.

The difference between Sydney under Roos and Melbourne under Roos has been that the Demons have not been able to put up big scores. That is the second part of the rejuvenation under Roos.

Showers are forecast for today and if they eventuate they are likely to slow down the match.

"In the last few games we've been able to keep sides to pretty low scores but we haven't scored a lot ourselves,'' Vince said.

"But I guess if it's wet, it will suit us — low-scoring game again.

Melbourne midfielder Bernie Vince takes a look at the new Adelaide Oval. Picture: Sarah Reed.

"Our attack is probably something that's let us down a bit but getting Chris Dawes back has been great.

"Hopefully our attack can lift a bit, but (playing) in the wet might suit us.

"Being realistic where we came from, coming off winning two games last year, 'Roosy' thought the best was to turn that around was to get our defence right first, to really try to choke the opposition and stop them scoring.

"The offence hasn't been put on the backburner but that's the thing we've found the toughest: to score. And it hasn't helped to have all of our key forwards out.

"That's probably the thing we've been working on the most.

Melbourne is acutely aware of Adelaide's potential to score freely after studying Vince's old side closely over the first six rounds.

"They're a very attacking side and they've scored big,'' Vince said.

"Even in the games that they've lost it's been a real shoot-out.

"We're going to try to stop what their strength is and that's their high scoring.

"We've just got to make sure we tackle well — all the little things — (winning) the contested ball and get the ball going our way and hopefully stop their outside run.

"They build up from half back and can then attack well. We need to shut down guys like David McKay and Brodie Smith and those sort of guys who really create that run.

"They've got some real guns in there that can really hurt us but if the surface is a bit wet it might suit us a bit more."

He is aware of the close attention he is likely to receive in the midfield.

Sam Kerridge, who took his old number, is likely to be standing right next to Vince at the opening bounce.

"Seventeen (No. 17) was pretty close to me because I used to wear it but looks like I might be wearing it again tomorrow (Saturday),'' Vince said.

Bernie Vince in action for Melbourne. Picture: Wayne Ludbey. Source: News Corp Australia

HAPPY HOMECOMING FOR BERNIE

BERNIE Vince maintains he has no hard feelings over his departure from the Crows and could not look forward more to today's match at Adelaide Oval.

He remains close to the players — and he was one of the club's most popular figures when he played for Adelaide.

Vince is also enjoying his time at his new club, as much as it was a traumatic time when he was traded.

"No, none (hard feelings) at all from me,'' Vince said.

"I'm very good mates with all the guys still and I'll certainly say G'day to them after and there's no hard feelings from my side.

"I keep in pretty close contact with a lot of them anyway.

"I'm sure it will a bit of fun out there. It probably be a little bit weird, too, because I haven't played them yet.''

Vince loved the look at Adelaide Oval, the one he just missed calling his home ground.

But his new digs aren't bad, either.

"Yeah, well, I get to play at the MCG every week,'' Vince said with a cheeky smile.

"You could argue that one as well. But I love playing anywhere, just love playing footy for a job.''

He wasn't sure what to expect from the local supporters.

Vince said he would try to shut it out, regardless of the reaction to him playing against the Crows for the first time.

"It'll be an interesting one but I can't really answer that one,'' Vince said.

"It'll be up to the supporters how they treat me.

"But I don't think it will worry me either way too much. It'll probably be a bit better if they don't boo me but we'll see what happens.''

Vince lives in Melbourne's inner-city suburb of Richmond now, not far from the MCG, and speaks highly about his new lifestyle.

But he conceded there had been some nerves before he completed the shift.

"It was the unknown, going over there, not knowing what to expect,'' Vince said.

"But the boys and the coaches and the club have been awesome.

"I've settled in really well and Melbourne feels like home now.''

Read More..

Saving Dees takes more than one man

Coach and saviour Paul Roos talks to his players. Picture: Wayne Ludbey. Source: News Corp Australia

PAUL Roos is the first proven coach - and premiership mentor - at the Melbourne Football Club since Ron Barassi made his grand return in 1981 with a five-year plan ... and with the image of a messiah.

Football clubs do make a habit of reliving history. The question with Roos is: Has Melbourne finally learned one man cannot save its club?

The Demons are renowned for seeking saviours.

Barassi failed, simply under the burden of being asked to carry Melbourne to salvation on and off the field - remarkably after the Demons had undermined his mentor, Norm Smith, in 1965 when its hierarchy feared having one man stand bigger than its club.

Stan Alves started his VFL senior career as Barassi left Melbourne for Carlton in '65.

He finished his 226-game journey at North Melbourne with Barassi as his coach.

"At North Melbourne, Ron Barassi was an outstanding coach because all he did was coach - and he never had to step out of that role because he had a strong support mechanism around him," Alves says.

Adelaide coach Brenton Sanderson admits Taylor Walker could have played in the AFL this week, instead he'll be making his return in round nine while his teammates take on the Melbourne Demons and former teammate Bernie Vince.

"Ron went back to Melbourne as the guru ... and not just as a coach, but in marketing, fundraising. And when the playing list was nowhere near what he had at North Melbourne, you can't work miracles."

Roos, 50, has returned to coaching - after a two-year stint in the media - in an era when AFL coaches are part of the marketing and corporate dollar chase.

But, as Geelong proved with Mark Thompson in 2006, there is a danger when a coach takes on much more than coaching.

Roos also has inherited a player list that has managed just eight wins in 2011, four in 2012 and two last season - and a football club that is seen to have failed with its recruiting and has infrastructure that appears inferior to the league's pacesetters.

Against this backdrop, can one man again try to save the Melbourne Football Club?

"Absolutely not," Roos says. "And we have enough history lessons in this era to highlight that.

"Geelong and Hawthorn are not about just the coach or the chief executive. And my experiences at Fitzroy and Sydney emphasise the importance of a collective effort - and getting the right people in the right positions.

"Ultimately, it will be the players who have the biggest say ..."

Much is made of Melbourne's recruiting - and the lack of development of players taken with prize draftees. Did the Demons' recruiting scouts err? Or is the development program at Melbourne a failure?

In the late 1960s Melbourne simply failed to recruit quality. It lived to the belief players still valued the honour of being a Demon and earning MCC membership after five years on the football club's list.

"It was terrible," Alves recalls.

"Players were identified ... and they'd finish up going to other clubs. The game was becoming professional - and Melbourne did not see the need to (pay)."

Today, Roos has a draft that does not let players slip. His reputation as a Hall of Fame player and a premiership coach at Sydney, allows Roos to lure targets such a Bernie Vince who thought he would be a one-club player at Adelaide.

But now that Roos is on the inside - rather than debating the "recruiting v development" question on the couch for the Fox Footy Channel - what does he make of this log-running question.

"I don't know yet - not after six rounds," Roos answers.

"I don't know what the players have been told or taught - and it hard to take on the burden of what has happened here in the past five years.

"As much as I understand the frustration of the Melbourne supporters, my task is to look to the future - to develop this list as quick as I can. That is all I can do at this time."

So where is Melbourne today? Apparently, at ground zero.

"I'm not happy to with the term 'rebuilding'," Roos said. "We are in the process of trying to play AFL footy - we are a team that has not played AFL football in a long time. Our challenge is to do that on a weekly basis.

"In the short-term, we have to set minimum standards for what is demanded in the AFL on a weekly basis. We're into finding out who can and who can't meet those standards. Good clubs go through that process.

"How long will that take? That depends on talent - look at Hawthorn and Geelong. Great talent creates great teams."

The image of the late Dean Bailey working out of a moveable hut when he coached Melbourne (2008-11) continues another theme that lingers with Alves from the end of the Smith era.

"We were not up to speed," Alves recalls of the infrastructure at Melbourne in the late 1960s. "We had to finish training early because we had no lights - and on the way home I would pull up to Richmond's ground to see them work under Tom Hafey. They would train longer than us. We were caught in a time warp."

Roos says Melbourne is also lost in a crowd of 10 Victorian-based teams in an 18-club national competition.

"Like a lot of teams, Melbourne is trying to find its identity again ... you can get lost in this competition," he said.

Barassi had a five-year plan. Roos intends to be at Melbourne for at least two, perhaps three seasons - and with a successor in place by the end of this year. Alves hopes Roos reconsiders. So does that mean he thinks one man can save Melbourne?

"No," Alves says. "Paul Roos is a fantastic appointment - and having Peter Jackson as the club's chief executive is just as crucial.

"Together, they have to build new infrastructure at Melbourne - and when you compare Melbourne to the structure they have around the coach at Geelong and Hawthorn, you see the Demons are coming from a long way back."

Is Roos prepared to be more than a short-term coach at Melbourne?

"No - I am clear what I have to do and what I signed up to do," Roos said.

Clearly, one man cannot save Melbourne.

Melbourne coach Paul Roos celebrates the win against Carlton with his players. Picture: Wayne Ludbey. Source: News Corp Australia

DEMONS IN HELL

MELBOURNE is the world's oldest football club - formed on July 10, 1858 - and a foundation member of the VFA and the VFL (that is today the AFL).

In 1964 the Demons won their 12th VFL flag, ranking second only to Collingwood as the competition's most-successful club. In the 50 years since this triumph, Melbourne has:

WON no flag and fallen to fourth in the league premiership rankings - behind Carlton (16), Essendon (16) and Collingwood (15).

PLAYED in just two grand finals - 1988 (losing to Hawthorn) and 2000 (losing to Essendon).

COMPETED in just 12 final series - with a 23-year gap between the 1964 grand final and the 1987 major round. The last finals appearance was a semi-final loss to Fremantle in Perth in 2006.

CLAIMED seven wooden spoons - 1969, 1974, 1978, 1981, 1997, 2008 and 2009.

CONTEMPLATED a merger with Hawthorn in 1996.

FALSE PROPHETS

MELBOURNE'S greatest period of success - six premierships from eight grand finals from 1954 to 1964 - was achieved under the legendary stewardship of coach Norm Smith. The Demons have repeatedly sought a "saviour" to restore the club's premier standing in Australian football - and learned no man can save Melbourne on his own.

That challenge even beat the great Ron Barassi who returned to the club as coach - after his success at Carlton and "miracle" at North Melbourne - in 1981.

He inherited talented youth - the Demons' under-19s played in three consecutive grand finals and won flags in 1981 and 1983 - but the seniors ranked last (12th) in Barassi's first season, 8th, 8th, 9th and 11th during his five-year plan.

Barassi later said: "In the five years we were there, I think we raised the level of the club quite substantially. Melbourne reached the preliminary final two years after we left, and the grand final the year after that. I felt we did some of the ground work."

THE NEW SAVIOUR?

PAUL ROOS

THE man who ended VFL-AFL football's longest premiership drought - the 72-year wait at South Melbourne-Sydney - is the 12th man to coach Melbourne since Norm Smith left the Demons in 1967.

Paul Roos returned to coaching this year - after two seasons as a media commentator - with a two-year contract and option for a third season. He has taken on one of the toughest jobs in Australian football with, reportedly, the richest contract ever offered to a coach: $1.5 million a season.

"IT is a fantastic appointment, but I hope he stays longer - it is not a two-year job."

Former Melbourne player and St Kilda coach STAN ALVES.

Read More..

Magpie goes Solo in AFL Star Wars epic

Collingwood star Dane Swan is a natural for the Han Solo role. Source: HeraldSun

YOU may have noticed a distinct Star Wars flavour about this week's round of footy.

While the AFL isn't officially calling it Star Wars Round, characters from the famous film series are popping up at press conferences and photo opps and clubs are flogging Star Wars T-shirts and merchandise (although original plans to feature Mick Malthouse as Darth Vader were binned by the Blues).

It's all to coincide with Sunday May 4 — international Star Wars Day: "May the fourth be with you".

It got us to thinking what a footy team from the Star Wars universe might look like.

To get us started, we've matched each character to a current AFL player — via similarities in playing style rather than appearances, it must be said.

Geelong players (from left) Jordan Murdoch, James Kelly and George Burbury get into the spirit of the Star Wars themed-round. Picture: Mitch Bear Source: News Corp Australia

A long time ago in a galaxy far, far away, from the backline ...

FULL-BACKS

Joel Patfull (Brisbane Lions)

Stormtrooper: A reliable defender and dual best-and-fairest winner who gets the job done every week with little fanfare and even less recognition.

Dustin Fletcher (Essendon)

General Grievous: The ageless stalwart of Essendon's backline. At times, seems to have four arms as he manages to find a way to spoil his opponents.

Josh Gibson (Hawthorn)

Imperial Guard: Stands like a sentinel in the Hawks' defensive 50m. Constantly at attention and ready to unleash a timely fist.

The multi-limbed General Grievous would be tough to beat in one-on-one contests. Source: Supplied

HALF-BACKS

Corey Enright (Geelong)

Wedge Antilles: Like the Rebel Alliance general, Enright launches guerilla raids on the enemy from the half-back line.

Luke McPharlin (Fremantle)

Admiral Ackbar: It's a trap! ... sorry we couldn't help ourselves. McPharlin marshals the stingiest defence in the league. He bears no resemblance to a giant fish.

Ryan Crowley (Fremantle)

Darth Maul: Appears at his opponent's side like a malevolent shadow and cuts them down. Can pinch an opponent 300 times without an umpire noticing.

Which of these two guys would you rather have standing next to you at a centre bounce? Source: Supplied

CENTRES

Dale Thomas (Carlton)

Anakin Skywalker: We're not saying Carlton is the dark side ... but many Collingwood fans believe Daisy gave up his soul.

Chris Judd (Carlton)

Darth Vader: Was once the pin-up boy of the AFL but as he's got older has used some dark tactics (pressure points and chicken wings). Anakin and Darth are both at Carlton ... just sayin.

Joel Selwood (Geelong)

Boba Fett: Willing to get his hands dirty to get the job done. A ruthless leader who can escape a tackle with a simple shrug of his shoulders.

Boba Fett is a clone and Joel is one of four Selwoods to play AFL. Coincidence? Source: Supplied

HALF-FORWARDS

Lenny Hayes (St Kilda)

Obi-Wan Kenobi: The veteran has done his apprenticeship and is now a midfield master. As he nears the end, he is passing on his wisdom to the Saints bunch of young guns.

Tyrone Vickery (Richmond)

Jar Jar Binks: Tall, clumsy and often criticised. Sorry Tyrone, but you fit the bill perfectly.

Cyril Rioli (Hawthorn)

Ewok: Small and dangerous. Is there a better way to describe Cyril? Defenders never know when he will strike.

Weesa not kicking any goals. That's why you no liking us meesa thinks. Source: Supplied

FULL-FORWARDS

Hayden Ballantyne (Fremantle)

R2-D2: The Fremantle goalsneak is handy in a fight but is perhaps best known for annoying his rivals into a state of despair possibly (although we can't confirm this) with high-pitched beeping noises.

Travis Cloke (Collingwood)

Chewbacca: An old fashioned "gorilla" full-forward, Cloke can handle two defenders at once. Few are brave enough to stand in his way. He hasn't yet pulled a defender's arms out of his sockets after a loss, but it's not a huge stretch of the imagination.

Will Minson (Western Bulldogs)

C-3PO: The droid is fluent in six million forms of communication. Will can speak two languages. We think that's close enough. Regarded as the smartest footballer going around.

R-2 says the chances of victory are 725 ... to one. Source: HeraldSun

RUCKS

Aaron Sandilands (Fremantle)

Wookie: The Dockers big man gets a game for one simple reason: He was very nearly in an actual Star Wars movie. Gerard Whately revealed on AFL360 this week that the 211cm Sandilands was reportedly offered a contract to play a wookie on the big screen before Fremantle picked him in the wookie — sorry, rookie draft.

Dane Swan (Collingwood)

Han Solo: The quintessential rebel. Swan is one of the few characters left in the AFL with his various tattoos and famous training standards.

Gary Ablett (Gold Coast)

Luke Skywalker: It has been many years since young Ablett stepped out of the shadow of his famous father. The hero of the AFL, Gaz can pick up 30 touches with ease and kick goals from 50m out as easily as bulls-eyeing womp rats.

Gary Ablett thrives in any conditions. Source: HeraldSun

COACH

Paul Roos (Melbourne)

Yoda: Verging on legendary status after delivering Sydney its first premiership since 1933 and arriving at Melbourne with huge expectations. Hired to mentor the Demons' talented but directionless youngsters.

Paul Roos' message to Demon fans is simple: Patience you must have. Source: HeraldSun

Read More..

Tex set for Collingwood clash

Taylor Walker in action for Adelaide's SANFL side against Glenelg. Picture: Sarah Reed Source: News Corp Australia

Adelaide are expected to continue their cautious approach with Taylor Walker with the forward set to play for the Crows' state league side against Port Adelaides reserve team on Sunday.

TAYLOR Walker will play in Adelaide's Round 9 blockbuster against Collingwood if he gets through Sunday's SANFL clash unscathed, according to coach Brenton Sanderson.

Sanderson said the club thought long and hard about playing its ace key forward against Melbourne at Adelaide Oval tomorrow but felt Walker would benefit from a second consecutive SANFL hit-out after missing 12 months following a knee reconstruction.

If he gets through Sunday's game he will be rested from the SANFL next week in preparation for the May 15 match against the Magpies.

The Crows have the AFL bye next week.

SLOANE: WE'LL TARGET BERNIE

"Tex is ready to play (AFL) but we're sticking with the original plan of giving him two games in the SANFL, which will give him the best preparation to play in the AFL," Sanderson said.

"He will go to the AFL program after this round.

"He'll have the 10-day break with the AFL squad leading into the Collingwood game.

"If he plays well and gets through the (Port) Magpies game up in Clare we would be foolish not to play him against Collingwood.

"He was really close to playing this week and he looks strong, he looks fit and we're really excited to get Tex back in the mix after 12 months out."

Read More..

Power won’t stop now it’s top

Port Adelaide defender Tom Jonas says the Power's painful past is helping them work towards a prosperous future as they prepare to take on GWS in Canberra on Saturday.

Port Adelaide defender Tom Jonas, who has extended his contract with the club. Picture: Sarah Reed. Source: News Corp Australia

PORT Adelaide is drawing motivation from its horror seasons before Ken Hinkley's arrival to remain on course after reaching the top of the AFL ladder.

The memories of 10 and 20-goal beltings remain raw in the minds of the players who were in struggle town only three seasons ago and they serve as a sharp reminder of what can happen if they lose their focus.

Defender Tom Jonas, who has been through both the good and the bad, said the occasional look in the rear view mirror would add fuel to the Power's finals tilt this season.

There is no more obvious clue trigger than the loss to GWS in 2012, which led to Matthew Primus' sacking.

"I think moments like those a couple of years ago make you appreciate how well we're going now and not take it for granted,'' Jonas said.

"Just take every day as it comes and keep improving ... not wanting to go back there.''

There is now a completely different mindset at Port.

Appreciate the pressure and the fact that the Power is being hunted, rather than seeing each week as a threat.

Jonas outworks Geelong's George Burbury. Picture: Sarah Reed. Source: News Corp Australia

"Over the past few years we've had a lot of challenges and (now) we love them,'' Jonas said. "Keep throwing them our way.''

Jonas, who has just signed a new contract, also spoke of the changes that have happened under Ken Hinkley and how the club was embracing the sense of expectation that is now surrounding the Power.

But Port had decided to accept and enjoy the pressure of being on top rather than playing it down.

"We've had a fair bit of expectation all year, so far,'' Jonas said.

"But we've done really well with that.

"We've been to Perth and got a good win, had a really good win against Geelong on the weekend.

"We have high expectations internally, work really hard and do what we can to keep improving.''

The change of form at Alberton made his decision to sign and easy one.

"Kenny's been great,'' Jonas said.

"He's got a great support network but he's also has a massive focus on doing the little things right and have really high expectations from his players.

"He's really riding us and having really high expectations from the group.''

Hinkley, in turn, was quick to make a fuss of Jonas's improvement and commitment.

The other quality that stood out to Hinkley was his versatility.

"He's now announcing himself as a really strong defender, he can play tall, he can play small," Hinkley said.

"He's also one of our really strong young leaders at the club, he's already in the leadership group and he's just gone from strength to strength.

"He's an important part of our backline and an important part of our whole football club so it's really exciting to have him signed on.

"He's the example you want to look for, when you're looking for people who want to get the most out of themselves.

"Tom does everything he can to make himself the best player he can be and the best person he can be."

Read More..

Who will be victim of Tex’s return?

Veteran forward James Podsiadly may have to make way for Taylor Walker. Picture: Sarah Reed. Source: News Corp Australia

FOUR into three doesn't go.

And that's why Crows coach Brenton Sanderson is left with one of the toughest selection dilemmas in his three years in charge at West Lakes.

The return of power forward Taylor Walker - the club's best forward - from long term injury is a major boost for Adelaide.

Who should make way for Taylor Walker?

But it also leaves Sanderson with an embarrassment of key forward riches.

MORE: TEX CAN WALK RIGHT IN, SAYS BRENT REILLY

For a team which struggled for goals in Walker's absence last year, it is a good problem to have.

But it will also be causing Sanderson sleepless nights.

Taylor Walker in action for the Crows in the SANFL against Glenelg. Picture: Sarah Reed.

How does he fit Walker, who returned from 12 months out following a knee reconstruction in the SANFL last Friday night, veteran pick-up James Podsiadly, the rapidly improving Josh Jenkins and mobile tall Tom Lynch into the same side?

On paper, the names stack up well.

Offensively, Walker, Podsiadly, Jenkins and Lynch would appear to be an opposition coach's nightmare.

But with such a focus on defensive pressure and team balance in modern footy, playing all four in the one side is fraught with danger.

Sure, it can work on the odd occasion. But long term it will fail.

Gone are the days when key forwards didn't have to chase and apply pressure to the opposition. Now they are required to chase, press and tackle just like their smaller teammates.

High on each club's must-do instructions is the motto "what are you doing when you don't have the ball?''.

Rarely does a forward line consist of more than three talls. Most clubs take the three/three approach - three talls and three smalls.

The tall timber creates contests and wins contested aerial balls while the smalls are there to rove the contests and complement the big guys' work.

When Port Adelaide dropped key forward John Butcher a few weeks ago it went with a two/four attacking set-up, with Jay Schulz and Justin Westhoff as its talls.

Sometimes clubs can even opt for a one/five attack - depending on whether they have a standout key forward and a posse of clever, elusive small forwards.

What compounds Adelaide's scenario is that the three forward line talls it played in last Sunday's grinding nine-point win against the Western Bulldogs are all in good form.

Podsiadly and Jenkins both bagged three goals, won contested ball and moved well. Lynch roamed far and wide for 25 disposals, seven marks, two goals and a game-high four score assists.

None of them deserves the chop.

Geelong premiership star Podisadly has been Adelaide's forward 50 barometer. His experience and leadership has been vital in Walker's absence.

He averages an impressive 14 disposals, five marks, three tackles and 1.5 goals in the opening six rounds.

Lynch's stunning performance in his first full game of the season against the Dogs after overcoming a dislocated shoulder showed how important he is to the Crows in his role of linking the midfield to the deep lying forwards.

The mobile role he is able to play is a luxury few clubs have.

The athletic Jenkins past three matches, in which he has booted 11 goals, have been his best in Crows colours.

Unlike Adelaide's other tall forwards, he also can ruck and give Sam Jacobs a valuable breather from his heavy workload.

With Shaun McKernan preferred as the back-up ruck option in the pre-season and opening two rounds, Jenkins is now making up for lost time.

He is hungry and is clearly making every post a winner, averaging 15 disposals, eight marks and 2.75 goals in his four games this season.

The three talls have been well complemented by a posse of smalls, who are all playing their roles well.

These include Carlton pick-up Eddie Betts, who has been one of the best performed goalkicking small forwards in the past decade, Jared Petrenko as a defensive tackling inside-50 pressure machine and Matthew Wright and Rory Laird sharing that extra defensive role.

With resting midfielders Patrick Dangerfield, Scott Thompson and Rory Sloane also playing cameos inside 50, the Crows' once maligned attack is now a force to be reckoned with.

The stats don't lie.

Adelaide has been efficient in its front half, taking more marks inside forward 50 this season (12.3 average, ranked fifth in the AFL) than it did last year (11.2 average, ranked 13th).

It also has the fourth best percentage of kicks inside 50 resulting in a goal.

Clearly, given Walker's credentials, he will be the centrepiece of Sanderson's attack when he is fully fit and in form.

While there has been some hysteria about Walker's 12-disposal, 3.3 comeback game against Glenelg in the State League, I would give him at least one more match in the local competition before returning him to AFL ranks, especially given the good form of Adelaide's other tall forwards.

But Sanderson will then be backed into a corner and forced to make a big call.

Unless there is an unforeseen injury, one man will be the fall guy.

Podsiadly - as good as he has been - appears to be the player who could be forced out, given he plays a similar role to Walker.

He was the player brought to the club as insurance for Big Tex and he has performed admirably in the opening six rounds.

J-Pod will have a valuable role to play this season - even in defence where he has shown he can also play good footy - but with those around him currently in such good nick and Walker's return to the side imminent, I'm not sure the Crows can afford the luxury of playing both him and Tex inside the forward 50.

This unbalance could affect Adelaide's ability to apply great defensive pressure and subsequently force defensive turnovers.

Few would envy Sanderson's tough decision. But it's one he must make because four into three just doesn't work.

THE SUPER SIX

Adelaide's best starting forward line

F: Eddie Betts (goalkicking small), Josh Jenkins (key forward/ruck release), Jared Petrenko (defensive forward)

HF: Tom Lynch (tall, mobile lead-up forward), Taylor Walker (power forward), Matthew Wright (defensive forward, midfield rotation)

Read More..

Forget ‘Perth Curse’, bring on Cats

The umpire awards a free kick to battered and bruised Chad Wingard, left, after he was charged by West Coast defender Darren Glass, third from left. Picture: Justin Benson-Cooper. Source: News Corp Australia

PORT Adelaide says it is not concerned about the Perth Curse affecting its preparation for Sunday's home blockbuster against Geelong.

Three of the four sides who have played in WA this year have been well beaten the following week, with the past two, St Kilda and Essendon, appearing to struggle to back up physically after the tough road trip.

Bombers coach Mark Thompson questioned his players' rehabilitation after they were upset by the Saints the week after being smashed by Fremantle at Patersons Stadium.

But Power midfielder Hamish Hartlett played down concerns over the trip to WA affecting the players, noting that last week's courageous win against West Coast was played in the cool of night rather than the heat of the day.

"A lot of the teams that have come back from Perth have played when it was pretty hot, about 30-31 degrees,'' Hartlett said.

"We played in pretty cool conditions for Perth, so I don't think that took anything more out of us compared to any other game.''

St Kilda, Essendon and the Western Bulldogs have all lost the week after playing in WA this year, with only the Gold Coast (against struggling Brisbane) recording a win.
Easing the burden for Port is that it has the luxury of an eight-day break between games while travelling Geelong has only a six-day break, having played — and beaten — premier Hawthorn at the MCG on Monday.

West Coast Eagles suffer a frustrating fourth quarter wich sees them go down to Port Adelaide 56-70

Hartlett says because of the long break between games, the Power players will not need to do more recovery work and sway from their usual preparation.

"We won't need to prepare any differently,'' he said.

"We had a bit of a run-around on Tuesday, we'll train pretty flat out on Thursday and then have a light run on Saturday, so we'll go about things pretty normally.''

Hartlett said Port has a "few sore boys'' after what he described as a bruising encounter against the Eagles.
"(Jay) Schulz (split lip) is probably the main one — his face is a little bit mangled at the moment, but he'll be right,'' he said.

"Chad (Wingard) and Jackson (Trengove) are just a bit sore through their torso but nothing of any major concern.''

Hartlett said small forward Angus Monfries is making a strong bid to return from a two-match absence with a hamstring injury but he is likely to have to wait another week.

Triumphant Power players leave Patersons Stadium after beating the Eagles. Picture: Paul Kane.

Read More..

Mended Monfires ready to return

Angus Monfries is itching to return for the Power. Picture: Sarah Reed. Source: News Corp Australia

PORT Adelaide midfielder-forward Angus Monfries will push for selection this weekend after training freely at Adelaide Oval on Thursday morning.

Monfries injured his hamstring against North Melbourne in Round 3 and it was feared he would miss several weeks, but he has surprised fitness staff with his speedy recovery and runs like he is ready to play.

TREDREA: LOBBE POWER'S MOST IMPORTANT PLAYER

The former Bomber hurt himself when he was chasing a Brad Ebert kick halfway through the third quarter against the Kangaroos and immediately clutched his right hamstring.

Commentators at the ground feared it would be a long-term injury, if not at least the regulation three weeks that are prescribed for the majority of hamstring injuries.

Port's trading at Adelaide Oval was scheduled to be followed by an appearance at the Burnside shopping centre as the club continues a push to win fans and supporters in new markets.

Port plays Geelong this Sunday at Adelaide Oval/

Read More..

AFL report card: Your dux and dunce

Geelong ruckman Hamish McIntosh has revealed on AFL 360 he feared his career was over after a string of injuries.

Hawk Luke Hodge is held at bay by Steve Johnson. Picture: Wayne Ludbey Source: News Corp Australia

HOT: Matthew Jaensch: Has not put a foot wrong this campaign, Jaensch collected 29 disposals against Greater Western Sydney to take his season average to 24 — up 12 on last year.

NOT: James Podsiadly: Is yet to make the most of his second chance at a club devoid of fit and firing key forwards. J-Pod has kicked six goals in five games, inflated on the back of three against St Kilda.

Lion Dayne Zorko is relishing the opportunity to spend more minutes in the midfield. Picture: Simon Cross Source: News Corp Australia

BRISBANE

HOT: Dayne Zorko: Has thrived spending more time in the midfield with Simon Black (retired) and Daniel Rich (knee) out of the side. Zorko is doing plenty with and without the ball in hand.

NOT: Matthew Leuenberger: The big ruckman's numbers leave a lot to be desired, ranked 17th with 80 in hit-outs through the first month of football. Injuries don't help.

What you missed on TV last night

The Barometer- Round 6

SuperCoach Studs and Duds

CARLTON

HOT: Robbie Warnock: The 206cm ruckman has emerged as the pick of the tall stocks at Visy Park with Matthew Kreuzer going down injured. Warnock is currently the third most prolific tap ruckman in the business behind barnstorming Aaron Sandilands and 2013 All Australian Will Minson.

NOT: Jeff Garlett: Expected to make inroads following Eddie Betts' departure, Garlett, currently banished to VFL duties, has hardly fired a shot, kicking three goals in as many games.

Magpie Jack Frost brings down Aaron Black. Picture: Wayne Ludbey Source: News Corp Australia

COLLINGWOOD

HOT: Jack Frost: Swimming like a pro after being thrown in the deep end, Frost's scalps include Lance Franklin and Drew Petrie. He held Tom Hawkins for three quarters and was far from disgraced against barrage of Fremantle attacks in Round 1.

NOT: Taylor Adams: Made a handy debut in Round 1, but has struggled since for consistency. The sub's vest and a one-match ban for an off-the-ball hit on Joel Selwood hasn't helped his cause.

ESSENDON

HOT: Michael Hurley: Looks to be relishing his move in defence and for the time being — touch wood — his body is holding up to the rigours of AFL footy. If only he'd get a haircut.

NOT: Jake Carlisle: Was an All Australian contender when allowed to play solely in defence. Fast forward 12 months, Carlisle is being asked to play forward, back and pinch-hit in the ruck as the Bombers move to counter injuries and departures. Put simply, he doesn't look comfortable.

FREMANTLE

HOT: Matthew Pavlich: He's fit and firing on all cylinders. Pav has wound back the clock kicking 11 goals the past three weeks. Will need to continue in similar fashion if he's to spearhead an attack missing All Australian Michael Walters.

NOT: Nick Suban: Enjoyed a breakout season as the Dockers marched to their first Grand Final last year. This time around looks to be struggling, missed Round 1 (suspended) and started as the substitute on Saturday.

GEELONG

HOT: Hamish McIntosh: Working up to full fitness after spending the best part of two years on the sidelines injured. The former North Melboourne no. 1 ruckman gives Cats coach Chris Scott greater flexibility to play running machine Mark Blicavs around the ground. McIntosh is a strong contested and goalkicker when used deep in the forward line. Will only improve with more games under his belt.

NOT: Travis Varcoe: Like McIntosh has endured a series of injury setbacks, but with Steve Motlop out injured, Paul Chapman at Essendon and James Podsiadly in Adelaide, it was expected Varcoe would step up and impact the scoreboard. He's tracking OK but it's only going to get tougher when Motlop returns.

Gold Coast Suns star Jaeger O'Meara in action. Picture: Getty Source: Getty Images

GOLD COAST

HOT: David Swallow: Was all the rage during the pre-season and he's living up to expectation. Not only is he being used as a setup man out of defence, his ability to drift forward and kick goals makes him a valuable commodity.

NOT: Jaeger O'Meara: We're not quite in second-year blues territory, but O'Meara is simply not imposing himself as much as he did last year. The Rising Star is ranked fifth in Suns' disposals behind Gary Ablett, Dion Prestia, David Swallow and Michael Rischitelli.

GREATER WESTERN SYDNEY

HOT: Adam Treloar: Has taken giant strides in 2014 averaging 28 disposals a game — 14 of them contested. Treloar, drafted as a 17-year-old in 2011, enjoyed a strong pre-season under new coach Leon Cameron. With speed to burn and a thirst for the contest, Treloar looms large as one of the best young midfielders in the business.

NOT: Dylan Addison: Dropped after just three games, Addison is well and truly at the crossroads, forced to find touch in the NEAFL. It's not going to be easy for the former Western Bulldogs utility to break back into a Giants' side brimming with talent.

HAWTHORN

HOT: Bradley Hill: The 20-year-old speed machine showed signs of what he was capable of last year dazzling rivals with his speed and smarts. The problem was his tank would run dry by the main break. 12-months on and Hill is back to his blistering best — averaging 25 disposals a game — and playing out a solid four quarters.

NOT: Luke Hodge: It feels wrong even considering Hodge in this bracket, but the harsh reality is we've only seen glimpses of his best this season. The fearless leader is averaging 20 disposals a game — inflated by his 32 against Gold Coast in Round 4. Even yesterday he only had 13 at the final change before racking up eight more as the Hawks made their charge.

Melbourne youngster Jimmy Toumpas. Picture: Wayne Ludbey Source: News Corp Australia

MELBOURNE

HOT: Dom Tyson: The obvious class of Josh Kelly has heaped pressure on Tyson, but since arriving at the Demons via the 2013 trade period, the 20-year-old has been hard to fault. He'd be up there in the Melbourne best and fairest award after averaging more than 23 disposals in the first five rounds. Such is his impact, Carlton assigned Andrew Carrazzo to Tyson in Round 4. Time will tell whether the combination of Tyson and Salem will bear more fruit than No. 2 pick Kelly and pick No. 20 (on traded), but Tyson is certainly holding up his end of the bargain so far.

NOT: Jimmy Toumpas: Looked like a boy playing against men in his debut season, but the No. 4 pick enjoyed a bumper pre-season, improving his fitness and kicking four goals in Melbourne's intra-club match. However things haven't gone to plan since, he was dropped after Melbourne's Round 2 thumping against West Coast and spent the last three weeks in the VFL. Toumpas was a classy player in the juniors, but is yet to show he has the tools at AFL level.

NORTH MELBOURNE

HOT: Ben Cunnington: Has emerged from the shadows of injured leaders Andrew Swallow and Jack Ziebell as the Kangaroos' clearance specialist. He's tough, skilful, ultra-competitive and knows how to find space/time under pressure. It will be interesting to see how Cunnington fairs with Ziebell and Swallow back in the mix.

NOT: Shaun Atley: We're yet to see Atley at his explosive, line-breaking, best in 2014 after much hype during the off-season. The 21-year-old was expected to improve in leaps and bounds in his fourth AFL season, but we're yet to see him in full flight. Atley has played bit-part roles in the Kangaroos' three wins to day averaging 20 disposals — 11 handballs.

Power midfielder Ollie Wines bursts through Jack Redden's tackle. Picture: Sarah Reed Source: News Corp Australia

PORT ADELAIDE

HOT: Ollie Wines: It's hard to recall a more accomplished second-year AFL footballer. Well, Chad Wingard wasn't bad, but the only thing Wingard has on Wines at the moment is the fact he maintained his form for a full season. Wines is just five games into his second season and he looks as though it's his tenth. He is averaging just less than 25 disposals a game and more than six tackles in 2014. He's a jet.

NOT: John Butcher: Anyone who remembers Butcher's 10 goals in two weeks at the end of season 2011 has been waiting for the 197cm forward to step up and take the competition by the scruff of the neck. He kicked a bag in an intra-club game and all the noise out of Port Adelaide was saying Butcher has overcome his injury issues and was ready to be a regular senior player. However, after kicking just two goals in the first three rounds, Ken Hinkley lost patience with the 22-year-old and he was dropped.

Richmond forward Tyrone Vickery has his hands full in the VFL. Picture: Kris Reichl Source: News Corp Australia

RICHMOND

HOT: Matt Thomas: Thomas only played four games for Port Adelaide last year, but had a stellar SANFL season and tied for the Magarey Medal. He has been one of Richmond's best players in a frustrating start for the club, averaging a career-high 20 disposals and he was instrumental in Richmond's Round 2 win over Carlton. Playing in a lockdown role, Thomas would be one of the first picked by Damian Hardwick each week.

NOT: Tyrone Vickery: It's easy to pick on Vickery because of his laconic nature and tendency to regularly make a meal out of the most basic of situations. He has been criticised for his work ethic and defensive pressure when Richmond has been poor, but the flip side of this is he usually performs well when Richmond win — he kicked four goals in Round 2. He is a player of obvious talent, but in a team dying for a foil to Jack Riewoldt, Vickery has failed to step up to the plate in his sixth season and he was dropped after Round 4.

ST KILDA

HOT: Luke Dunstan: There was suspicion this young South Australian was a ready-made AFL midfielder and in five games he has made a liar of no one. Young midfielders are usually afforded the luxury to ease into the game on a wing or a flank, but Dunstan stepped into the centre square in his first game for a side missing a bevy of experienced players and hasn't looked back. In Round 3 against West Coast — playing at the AFL's most hostile venue — Dunstan had 29 disposals and kicked two goals in a game totalling 141 SuperCoach points.

NOT: Shane Savage: When Savage moved from Hawthorn to St Kilda, there was every indication the 23-year-old would flourish with more midfield minutes and greater responsibility. Savage showed at Hawthorn an ability to win the football inside and out of the contest and was a good finisher around goals. In his sixth AFL season and with 60 games under his belt, his time to arrive as a consistent AFL player is now, however he has floundered at St Kilda. His pre-season form was OK, but things have fallen apart in the season proper. Savage's highest SuperCoach score is 55 and was dropped after Round 4.

Sydney takes stock after its loss to North Melbourne. Picture: Getty Source: Getty Images

SYDNEY

HOT: Luke Parker: Parker is probably the only Sydney midfielder who has improved in 2014. It's hard to believe this 2012 premiership player is still 21 years of age and among the patchy form of his teammates, Parker has lifted his possession average to 24 a game. In a side which has struggled defensively, Parker is averaging five tackles per game and more than 100 SuperCoach points. He and Tom Mitchell were neck and neck at the start of this season, but Parker has taken his game to the next level, while Mitchell has gone the way of his senior teammates — south.

NOT: Dan Hannebery: You could throw a blanket over most of the Sydney side in the first month of the season and for that reason it's unfair to pinpoint one player, but we'll do it anyway. Dan Hannebery emerged as one of the elite midfielders in the competition last year, polling 21 Brownlow votes and winning All-Australian selection. He averaged more than 25 disposals and got 30 or more on seven occasions. This year he is averaging just more than 20 and his burst running and ability to win multiple involvements in a chain of play is non-existent.

WEST COAST

HOT: Luke Shuey: the 23-year-old set the MCG alight in Round 2, booting two goals from 30 touches against the Dees. He backed it up on the weekend with 28 possessions and five tackles against Port Adelaide. Overall, he's averaging 23 disposals in 2014. Shuey is no longer the future of the Eagles' midfield — he is the Eagles' midfield. And, he is starting to grow into that reputation.

NOT: Nic Naitanui: Dean Cox will not play forever, so Naitanui can't play second fiddle forever. The footy world is patiently waiting for the 23-year-old to step up and consistently produce big games and big numbers. Naitanui has never been a big goal kicker, but one goal from five games so far this season is not enough. More of a concern is that he's not accumulated more than 17 hit-outs in a match yet in 2014. How patient are you, Eagles fans?

Bulldogs captain Ryan Griffen takes a breather. Picture: Michael Klein Source: News Corp Australia

WESTERN BULLDOGS

HOT: Jack Macrae: He's only 19, but the Bulldogs young gun is already averaging elite midfielder. Macrae has accumulated at least 30 possessions in four of his five games. With a silky left foot and a ruthless hunger for the footy, the No. 6 pick has collected more uncontested possessions than any other player this season. Most impressively, Macrae has injected himself into games when they have been up for grabs, proving his love and will to perform on the big stage.

NOT: Ryan Griffen: A nagging back injury sustained during the pre-season has hampered Griffen's output so far in 2014. The 27-year-old skipper has showed signs of improvements in his past two outings, producing a ripping second half against GWS and picking up 32 touches against the Blues on Sunday.

Read More..

Cool hand Crouch gets rising star nod

Patrick Dangerfield has produced a Giant performance against GWS to help the Crows claim two straight wins.

Matt Crouch takes a mark against GWS. Source: Getty Images

ADELAIDE Crows midfielder Matt Crouch has been given a late birthday present with the round five NAB AFL Rising Star nomination.

One of the Crows' best players against Greater Western Sydney on Saturday, Crouch celebrated turning 19 yesterday.

VOTE: SHOULD RICHIE DOUGLAS BE DISCIPLINED?

His 28-possession performance in just three quarters was impressive in the Crows' 65-point win at Adelaide Oval. He was subbed out at three-quarter time.

Crouch made his AFL debut in round three against the Swans this season and has averaged 23 disposals since.

"I think I played all right on the weekend and I've been pretty consistent the last couple of weeks so I think that might have helped me get the award," Crouch said.

"I've learnt a lot at training in the preseason... that's helped a lot with my development."

Coach Brenton Sanderson says Crouch has a wise football head on his shoulders.

"Matt has a real hunger to learn more about the game and his role in the team," Sanderson said.

"He is also a fierce competitor, who makes great decisions under immense pressure."

Crouch was the Crows' first selection (at No. 23) in last year's draft.

Crouch's older brother and Crow teammate Brad earned a rising star nod in round 14 last year.

Read More..